Whoa! I have started to see random charges to client accounts on Google Places for items such as offers (coupons) and photos. These are clients who are set up for the $25 flat fee for tags each month, so Google is hitting the card on file for these additional charges. They aren’t big charges, but the problem is this seems to have come with no notice whatsoever and there is no information on when and how often these charges will hit.
I realize Google recently rolled out tags and any feature–especially a new one–is subject to change, but this one violates the spirit of Google Places, in my opinion.
Everywhere you look on Places, we’re urged to “Add flair to your listing” and “Enhance your listing” by adding more content, including coupons, photos and videos. That’s fair, but nowhere does it say you will be charged for creating a better listing.
I went back to the source to make sure I’d not overlooked anything in the fine print of terms and conditions. Since I couldn’t find anything anywhere inside the Places listing about charges for coupons or photos, I wondered if this was mentioned under billing details for tags.
But even under Google’s info on Advertising options: How much do tags cost, and how am I billed? it said exactly what it said previously, which was nothing about charges for coupons or photos. It does say if any fees change, you will be given at least 30 days notice.
Now here’s the kicker! I went back in to edit the listing to consider removing photos and I see this message from Google:

Warning: If you remove all your photos, your tag will be deactivated.
So, the client paid for tags, but they were charged for photos without notice, and if the photos are removed, their tag will be deactivated.
Upon further investigation, I click to change the tag and discover the source of this linkage between coupons, photos and tags. Another message from Google:

Note: In an effort to continue to improve our tags quality, we have decided to phase out the website tag type. You may continue to use your current website tag as is, or change your tag type at this time. If you decide to change your tag type, you will not be able to use the website tag type again.
Seems tags can no longer simply promote your website, but they are now for promoting “flair” on your listing.
There are two things that bother me about these changes in Google Places. One, the fact that the tag to promote your website has been removed means you’re paying for a tag that links to Google Places, not your own site. I suspect that the percentage of visitors that go to a Places page, but never click through to the owner’s site will be quite high. This reflects the growing trend of engines providing information essentially within the search results and visitors never click through to websites.
Secondly, this development continues to further blur the line between organic and paid search. Since Places are served up for organic searches, this comes down to paying for enhancements in the hopes of increasing organic visibility. (Of course, if you look at it that way, you could say tags–randomly charged or not–are a bargain.) Not that I’m an idealist, but I need to believe there’s still some editorial integrity in the algorithm.
So, back to the issue at hand–what to do in response to these changes?
I’m considering deactivating tags since I have no idea what charges to anticipate. Additionally, statistics provided by Google Places appear unreliable to me, so they’re no help in determining effectiveness of tags.
Have you been surprised by random charges in your Google Places account? If so, what did you do about it?